Visibly, Obviously, or Apparently Intoxicated
How States Word the Intoxication Standard
States describe the required level of intoxication differently: “visibly intoxicated” (New Jersey, Michigan, Missouri, Oregon), “apparently under the influence” (Washington, Utah, Vermont), “obviously intoxicated” (Texas), and “noticeably intoxicated” (Ohio). Some states add a knowledge element or a higher burden of proof, and the wording can decide what evidence matters.
By Ryan Dahlstrom, dram shop and overservice expert witness. Last reviewed November 5, 2026.
The Standards Side by Side
| State | Wording | Extra element |
|---|---|---|
| Washington | Apparently under the influence | Barrett v. Lucky Seven Saloon (2004) |
| Utah | Apparently under the influence; knew or should have known | Also under 21 and interdicted persons |
| Vermont | Apparently under the influence | Negligent furnishing |
| New Jersey | Visibly intoxicated | Exclusive remedy against licensees |
| Michigan | Visibly intoxicated | 120-day notice |
| Indiana | Visibly intoxicated | Actual knowledge |
| Missouri | Visibly intoxicated | Clear and convincing evidence; knowingly served |
| Oregon | Visibly intoxicated | Clear and convincing evidence |
| Tennessee | Visibly intoxicated | Beyond a reasonable doubt |
| Colorado | Visibly intoxicated | Willfully and knowingly |
| Ohio | Noticeably intoxicated | Knowingly sold (off premises) |
| Kentucky | Already intoxicated | Reasonable person should know |
| Illinois | Sale caused the intoxication | No visible intoxication element; caps |
What the Wording Changes
Appearance-based standards put the focus on what the patron looked like. Knowledge standards add questions about what the server actually saw or knew. Higher burdens of proof raise the value of clear records and consistent testimony. Missouri even defines visible intoxication as “significantly uncoordinated physical action or significant physical dysfunction.”
Frequently Asked Questions
Which states use visibly intoxicated?
Among the states summarized here: New Jersey, Michigan, Indiana, Missouri, Oregon, Tennessee, Colorado, and Montana.
Which states use apparently under the influence?
Washington, Utah, and Vermont.
Is BAC enough to meet these standards?
Usually not on its own. Missouri’s statute says BAC is not prima facie evidence of visible intoxication.
Need help applying your state’s standard? Call (702) 696-8745 or request a case review.